Friday, July 21, 2023

Book review : Kurt Seyt and Shura by Nermin Bezmen

Kurt Seyt 'n' Shura
by Nermin Bezmen

My rating: 2 of 5 stars

I wanted to give this book 5 stars, but I have to give it 2!

I read also, at the same time, the 3rd sequel SHURA (the third book completes the scenes of the first, while I avoided reading the 2nd book because it is about Seyit and his life with his wife Murvet and I want to avoid it ) , so I'll write the same review in the 2 books, indeed it'all concerning the same story and characters.

I start by saying that I fell in love with this love story and its protagonists by watching the 2014 TV series, which I have seen several times in the original language with English subtitles and which I am currently watching with Italian dubbing.

(view spoiler) but while the writers presented a truly romantic, passionate and sincere love story, staged by actors very good, as well as beautiful, the book, from which I expected something even bigger and more profound, completely ruined my pleasure from the TV series.

They say that books are better than movies or TV series, but I have learned never to read books whose characters I love from the series, because everything is different and they have often disappointed me .
This only applies if you first read the book and love it, if instead you first watch stories on the screen and love what you see, the book in 70% of cases will disappoint you because of the many differences about characters and scenes.

Yet this time I was so obsessed with this romance that I longed for more, to know more.
I wanted to have even more descriptions of this beautiful and pure love.... SPOILER:
This is where the disappointment comes in!
(view spoiler)
It really disgusted me. This is not love.

I'd like to make a more complete review, I've tried, but there's too much to write, and I can't... but I want to say 2 things:
1) I didn't have a book in English or in my own language, I did a Google translation, from Turkish to Italian, but it's neither this nor the author that disappointed me, it was the characters as they are behave meanly in reality.
I have not seen a strong big love, but only physical passion without anything else from Seyit and the first crush and first experience of Shura that turn into dedication, hope and love for a man who will always disappoint her and which then lead to other wrong relationships.

2) I desperately wanted to believe that it had really been a great and true love despite everything and Seyit's letter to Shura (view spoiler), for an instant made me believe that deep down he too had always regretted her and regretted having sent her away... but after reading so many interviews with the author and finding many contradictions... I wonder if this letter is not just a mere invention.

Forgive my English, I'm Italian and besides the difficulty in writing in a foreign language, I'm too negatively shocked by what I've read... so I probably wrote worse than usual.

Friday, July 14, 2023

Book review : Death of a Bookseller by Bernard J.Farmer

Death of a Bookseller:
The 100th British Library Crime Classic
by Bernard J. Farmer

My rating: 3 of 5 stars

It wasn't bad, I liked it enough to get to the end, but I wouldn't suggest it to a friend and for certain it will not be among the books I will read a second time.

Sergeant Wigan, escorts a drunk man home one night to keep him out of trouble and the man introduces himself as Michael Fisk and explains that he deals in rare books. He has been out celebrating his last discovery : a John Keats’ personal inscribed copy of Endymion.

The two become friends and the book collector teaches Wigan all the tricks to discovering and collecting rare editions.
But one day Mike Fisk, the collector, is found dead and despite the arrest of a person, Sergeant Wigan wants to find out who, according to him, is the real killer.

The first half of the book flowed well, but it wasn't totally engaging for me, I didn't feel the unbridled desire to resume reading every time I had to interrupt.

In the second half of the book the mystery thickens and becomes more engaging, however I must admit that there are some rather absurd contradictions :
________ WARNING : SPOILER ! __
1) a good and nice man who however wants to summon the devil... well, for me it is a contradiction that is not acceptable.
2) a psychopathic person who often tries to kill his brother and who hides sadomasochistic books, but then in the end after having hosted an old lady, she burns all those horrendous books.. has she suddenly become normal and sane? Come on !
3) a villain who confesses to a murder because if he doesn't confess the devil will be summoned and the devil will turn his mother into a rat ... hey come on ! The book is set in the 50's and not in the middle ages, who can believe such threats?
4) a collaborator of the detective, suddenly disappears and Wigan doesn't care too much about what might have happened to him ... not seeing him, he thinks he will wait a few more days to look for him, even though he knows that the situation could be dangerous ... and then in reality he doesn't even look for the man!
Wigan learns of the collaborator's death only when in the end the killer confesses to the second crime (which he does spontaneously, in fact Wigan only investigates the first murder), inconceivable!
________ END OF THE SPOILER __

Also, though it is nice that the detective in question finds external collaborators...well, there are some chapters where the protagonist does nothing or almost nothing and it is the others who carry out the real detective work.
Even in the finale, the most decisive work is done by another character.

In any case, the reading is smooth and the book can be read in two or three days.

I gave 3 stars because Wigan is a pleasant main role character and the mystery, overall, is interesting since there are several suspicious characters and until the end you can't guess who really could be the murderer.

I apologize for my English, it's not my native language :-)

Join me on FB

____________ LIBRO ORA DISPONIBILE ANCHE IN ITALIANO !

Ecco la mia opinione:

Non è stato male, mi è piaciuto abbastanza per arrivare alla fine, ma NON lo consiglierei ad un amico e di certo non sarà tra i libri che rileggerò una seconda volta.

Il sergente Wigan, una notte accompagna a casa un uomo ubriaco per tenerlo fuori dai guai e l'uomo si presenta come Michael Fisk e spiega che si occupa di libri rari. È uscito per celebrare la sua ultima scoperta: una copia personale di John Keats del suo Endymion ( poema del 1817) con tanto di iscrizione dell'autore.

I due diventano amici e il collezionista di libri insegna a Wigan tutti i trucchi per scoprire e collezionare edizioni rare. Ma un giorno Mike Fisk, l'esattore, viene trovato morto e nonostante l'arresto di una persona, il sergente Wigan vuole scoprire chi, secondo lui, sia il vero assassino.

La prima metà del libro scorre bene, ma per me non è stato molto coinvolgente, non sentivo la voglia sfrenata di riprendere la lettura del libro ogni volta che dovevo interrompere...mentre quando un libro ti prende, non vedi l'ora di rituffarti nella lettura.

Nella seconda metà del libro il mistero si infittisce e si fa più avvincente, tuttavia devo ammettere che ci sono delle CONTRADDIZIONI piuttosto ASSURDE:
________ ATTENZIONE : SPOILER ! __
1) la vittima viene descritta come un uomo buono e simpatico, che però vuole evocare il diavolo... beh, scusate, ma per me è una contraddizione INACCETTABILE. Ma quale persona buona d'animo vorrebbe evocare il diavolo?
Se come il protagonista, facessi amicizia con una persona che "sembra" buona, ma che mi dice che adora i libri dell'occulto e di magia nera e sta cercando di evocare il diavolo, quella persona non mi vedrebbe più.
2) uno dei personaggi è una psicopatica, che spesso cerca di uccidere il fratello e che nasconde libri sado-masochisti, ma poi alla fine dopo aver ospitato un'anziana brava signora, brucia finalmente tutti quei libri orrendi.. è improvvisamente diventata normale e sana di mente? Ma dai !
3) il cattivo che confessa un omicidio perché sotto minaccia...si ma la minaccia è :se non confessa verrà convocato il diavolo e il diavolo trasformerà sua madre in un topo... ehi andiamo! Il libro è ambientato negli anni '50 e non nel Medioevo, quale assassino avrebbe confessato sotto tali minacce?
4) un collaboratore del detective, improvvisamente scompare e a Wigan non importa molto di quello che gli può essere successo... non vedendolo, pensa che aspetterà ancora qualche giorno per cercarlo, anche se sa benissimo che la situazione è pericolosa per chi sta indagando... e poi in realtà non cerca nemmeno l'uomo!
Wigan viene a sapere della morte del collaboratore solo quando alla fine l'assassino confessa il secondo delitto (cosa che fa spontaneamente, Wigan infatti indaga solo sul primo omicidio e della scomparsa del suo collaboratore non gliene importa poi tanto, nessuna preoccupazione in proposito) e dopo aver saputo della morte del collaboratore, il Sergente Wigan non fa una piega... inconcepibile!

________ FINE DELLO SPOILER __

Inoltre, per quanto sia piacevole che il l'investigazione sia svolta non da un solo personaggio, il detective in questione, ma altri personaggi da lui coinvolti nelal caccia al vero assasino... beh, ci sono dei capitoli in cui il protagonista, che fa parte delal polizia, non fa assolutamente nulla o quasi nulla e sono gli altri personaggi a svolgere il vero lavoro investigativo.

Anche nel finale, il lavoro decisivo ( scoprire e far confessare il colpevole ) viene svolto da un altro personaggio...ma che senso ha ? In ogni caso la lettura è scorrevole e il libro si legge in due o tre giorni.

Ho dato 3 stelle perché Wigan, tutto sommato, è un personaggio principale piacevole e il mistero, nel complesso, è interessante poiché ci sono diversi personaggi sospetti e fino alla fine non puoi davvero indovinare chi potrebbe essere davvero l'assassino.

Per quanto mi riguarda , comunque, Bernard J. Farmer è un autore che non leggerò più.

Friday, June 30, 2023

Giveaway : Free Printable July 2023 Calendar

A cutie things to download and print: next month calendar planning

Hello everybody ! :-D

Since graphic design is one of my passions and hobbies ( and I also was a graphic designer and web designer for 10 years ), I thought it would be nice to give you some little gift from time to time.

Here is a free printable July 2023 calendar to help you keep track of the days passing by and your deadlines, appointments, your family and friends birthdays, projects and more!

You see it here in a medium/little size but the original jpg size ( in pixels ) is 1634 x 1264, so you can click on the image to enlarge and then download it.
You can save it on your computer and upload it as you screen desktop or print it and keep it on your work desk or hang it on the wall.

I wish you can enjoy it and if you have some suggestion about size, please tell me.

I'm asking you only a little favore : before downloading it, please leave me a little greeting in the comments, saying your name and which country do you come from :-)
If I see that at least 5 people have downloaded the freebie, I will gladly prepare another one for the month of August and for the next few months.

Thanks for stopping by, wishing you a good day and a Happy July!!!

Join me on FB

Monday, June 26, 2023

Book review : City of Silence by Kim Wright

City of Silence
by Kim Wright

My rating: 4 of 5 stars

NOTE : _ I'm Italian, I hope I managed to explain everything clearly even if not in correct English _

4 stars, it means that I liked it, it caught my attention, but it's not among those I would read again in the future (as often happens with those I adore and I rate 5 stars).


WHAT I LIKED:

1_) I liked that although there were many characters on the line ( not only the detective group but many others ) that develop their own story, it's very easy to get involved in each character's life and events.

Some of those characters are pure invention, some other are real existed characters ( such as Queen Victoria, her granddaughters Ella and Alix, the oldest Tsar's son Nicky ( future Nicholas II ), a young revolutionary that will be known as Lenin ).
All stories and character's thoughts alternate from chapter to chapter, but I repeat:
it's very easy to follow everything, indeed the writing is flowing the events are reported in an orderly manner and with a certain suspense that makes you want to know more.

I also had a lot of fun searching Pinterest for photos of the Romanovs, lots of personal photos of their family, taken by themselves, since they loved photography and had their own cameras.
This took me longer to read the book, but also shows that the subject was captivating.

2_) Of course, in addition to the mystery of a double homicide, initially cataloged as a double suicide, plus a third homicide later on, we find ourselves in a novel full of historical notions and it pleased me a lot, while I was reading the novel, to investigate the pages of Wikipedia and between newspaper articles on the true facts told in the book ( and of course discover also what wasn't at all true )

3_) The whole story takes place in St. Petersburg, when the young Alix goes to visit her sister Elizabeth (married to a Russian Grand Duke, the brother of the tzar Alexander III _ true facts) accompanied by her grandmother Queen Victoria (false).
Although there are no striking descriptions of the city in the book, you can breathe the imperial air of those times and the ferment of the revolution that was already peeping out.


WHAT I DIDN'T LIKE:

1_) As I told before some facts are true and some others not. Of course, after all it's a fiction, but I find that the author perhaps exaggerated a little with author's license ( Queen Victoria in Russia ??? It never happened, she disliked them, as it also is said in the book. I just can't even imagine her
at Romanovs court, bowing to the Tsar ).

There are two or three things that in my opinion are too exaggerated inventions, one of which I don't mention because it would be a spoiler, which even remains unexplained at the end, a fact that the true story tells us didn't happen, but which in the book, concerning one of the main characters, it should be clarified and should ended differently, instead it has an epilogue contrary to the true story and that I didn't like.

2_) I liked the whole book except two chapter ( the second one and one towards the end ) in which the group of detectives discuss the old cases and the boss comes up with all his theories about how to investigate ( not THIS CASE, but in general )... HEY ! HOW BORING ! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Ok, I can accept a couple of pages about that, but a WHOLE ? ( 2 whole chapters )
If it doesn't concern the case of the book I'm reading: WHO CARES ?! )
Of course all opinions are subjective.
____

To conclude, I can say that I liked it quite enough. I was happy to have read a mystery with a different scenario than the usual, set during a fascinating and also so profoundly unfair and therefore dangerous at the same, time historical time.
I recommend it ( even if from other reviews I saw that people preferred the first and the second one in the series ).

Join me on FB

Wednesday, June 14, 2023

Book review : The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society by Mary Ann Shaffer

The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society
by Mary Ann Shaffer


My rating: 3.5 of 5 stars

It is an epistolary novel, set immediately after the end of the war and the protagonist collects a series of testimonies regarding the occupation on Guernsey Island and the life of its inhabitants. All singular characters among which the personality of Elizabeth McKenna emerges in particular.

Elizabeth is not present as a character, but everyone talks about her, her exuberance, her vitality, her courage, her intolerance towards abuses and injustices and everything, beautiful and ugly, that derives from her way of being .

The stories of the inhabitants are very unique and it is pleasant to read them, it seemed to me to have guests for tea and to hear them tell their anecdotes, some funny, some sad ... others that disgusted me a little and I would have sincerely preferred not to have details about it (roasted pig, killed cat, scabies on the head and some other rubbish ... we know that during the war it was like that, but the author could spare those description's details that made me sick ).

The real protagonist of the book is a young author who is contacted by one of the islanders, which leads to a close correspondence between her and all of them.

The novel, as I have already said, was pleasant and I rounded it up to 4 stars because although it is all a pure invention, behind all this there are years of research and true testimonies collected in the archives, so I consider this reading an enrichment.
BUT ... there is a big "but" to me:
__________ something was missing, something that kept me tied to the book.

I read this book to the end only because "I wanted to finish reading, hoping to find something that made it shine", but actually every time I stopped reading because I had other things to do... I was not sorry and every time I had free time to go on reading it, I found myself thinking about what I could choose as my next reading, which was more engaging.
____ THAT SAYS A LOT. THAT IS : NICE BOOK, BUT NOT ADDICTIVE ! ( Not to me anyway )

In the novel, the protagonist, a writer, after having collected many testimonies, does not know how to write a book that has a common thread and her publisher advises her to write it by revolving the story around Elizabeth.

Maybe in reality the author (not the protagonist of the book, but the real author) had the same problem, then she found a good way to report many events, but (in my opinion ) something that keeps one in suspense is missing.

Perhaps she thought she had inserted it with a love story, but actually there is no pathos regarding this nor regarding the fate of the character everyone is talking about.

When I got halfway through the book, I had the thought of abandoning it.
I've read a few reviews: some enthusiastic, some really contemptuous... Here comes my review which is halfway there.
I find the contemptuous reviews of this book really bad and disrespectful, but I don't even feel like including it among the small reading jewels of that period.

( Sorry for any English errors, it's not my mother tongue :-) )




Join me on FB

** ------------- **


DISPONIBILE ANCHE IN LINGUA ITALIANA__ RECENSIONHE IN ITALIANO :


Il club del libro e della torta di bucce di patata di Guernsey
di Mary Ann Shaffer


Si tratta di un romanzo epistolare, ambientato subito dopo la fine della guerra e la protagonista raccoglie una serie di testimonianze riguardanti l'occupazione dell'isola di Guernsey e la vita dei suoi abitanti. Sono tutti personaggi molto singolari, tra i quali emerge, in particolare, la personalità di Elizabeth McKenna.

Elisabeth non è presente come personaggio, ma tutti, o quasi, raccontano di lei, della sua esuberanza, della sua vitalità, del suo coraggio, della sua insofferenza verso i soprusi e le ingiustizie e di tutto ciò che, bello e brutto, ne deriva.

Le storie degli abitanti sono molto particolari ed è piacevole leggerle, mi è sembrato di avere ospiti per il tè e di sentirli raccontare i loro aneddoti, alcuni divertenti, altri tristi, altri ancora che mi hanno disgustata e sinceramente avrei preferito non avere dettagli in merito (maialino arrosto, gatto ucciso e scuoiato, scabbia sulla testa e qualche altra schifezza... sappiamo che durante la guerra era così, ma l'autrice poteva risparmiarsi questi dettagli che mi facevano venir da vomitare).

La vera protagonista del libro è una giovane autrice che viene contattata da uno degli isolani, il che porta a una fitta corrispondenza tra lei e tutti loro.

Il romanzo, come ho già detto, è stato piacevole e l'ho arrotondato a 4 stelle perché nonostante sia tutta una pura invenzione, dietro a tutto questo ci sono anni di ricerche e testimonianze vere raccolte negli archivi, quindi considero questa lettura un arricchimento.
MA ... c'è un grande "ma" per me:
__________ mancava qualcosa, qualcosa che mi teneva legata al libro.

Ho letto questo libro fino alla fine solo perché "volevo finire di leggere, sperando di trovare qualcosa che lo facesse brillare", ma in realtà ogni volta che dovevo interropmpere la lettura, perché avevo altro da fare... NONB MI TROVAVO DISPIACIUTA ( come accade con un libro che adori ) e ogni volta che avevo tempo libero per riprendere il romanzo, mi ritrovavo a pensare a cosa avrei potuto scegliere come lettura successiva, qualcosa che fosse più coinvolgente. QUESTO DICE MOLTO.CIOè : CARINO, MA NON AVVINCENTE.

Nel romanzo, la protagonista, scrittrice, dopo aver raccolto tante testimonianze, non sa come scrivere un libro che abbia un filo conduttore e il suo editore le consiglia di scriverlo facendo ruotare la storia attorno ad Elizabeth.

Forse nella realtà l'autrice ( non la protagonista del libro, ma la vera autrice ) ha avuto lo stesso problema, ha trovato un buon modo per riportare tanti eventi, ma manca quel qualcosa che tiene col fiato sospeso. Forse lei ha pensato di averlo inserito con una storia d'amore, ma in realtà non c'è pathos ne riguardo a questo ne riguardo alla sorte del personaggio di cui tutti parlano.

Quando sono arrivata a metà libro, ho avuto il pensiero di abbandonarlo.
Ho letto qualche recensione : alcune entusiastiche, altre veramente sprezzanti... Ecco ora è arrivata la mia recensione che si trova a metà strada.
Trovo veramente cattive ed irrispettose le recensioni sprezzanti su questo libro, ma non mi sento neppure di inserirlo tra i piccolo gioielli della lettura di quel periodo.

Saturday, June 03, 2023

Book review : The Musician's Daughter by Susanne Dunlap

The Musician's Daughter
by Susanne Dunlap

My rating: 3 of 5 stars

This is a very difficult review to do !!

--- (warning: English is not my native language, you might find form and grammar errors)---

I gave a 3 star rating, but it could have been 4 stars, but until halfway through the book ( and also a little bit after halfway ) I was convinced that I would have given 2 stars and no more!

I really struggled to go on reading this novel !!!!!!!!!!!!

Where do I begin to explain all these mixed feelings to you?

1) The plot is solid, really captivating, perhaps one of the most original plots that have happened to me in recent years and that captivated me as soon as I read the back cover.

___THE PLOT__ The story takes place in 18th century imperial Vienna.
The protagonist is a young musician, whose life is suddenly turned upside down by the murder of her father, also a musician at the orchestra at Prince Nicholas Esterhazy’s court, his valuable violin missing, and the only clue to his death a strange gold pendant around his neck.
The body, found in a Hungarian gypsy camp, is brought back home by musician friends of the father, all part of the orchestra of Haydn, the famous Austrian composer ... everything is very weird and Theresa wants to find out the truth and she begins to uncover a trail of secrets,blackmail and extortion...
---> how you can see, all looks like an engrossing tale set against a charming period background and enriched with music and light romance.

------ WHAT WENT WRONG THEN ?

I liked the story, but unfortunately the author told it flatly and without emphasis, at least for the first half of the book, or maybe for almost three quarters of the book!

For the first 8/10 chapters, there were practically no dialogues, only a dozen very short sentences.
Example :

1st sentence : Open up!

2nd one: what happens?

3rd one: I don't know !

...hey ...8 (or maybe 10) chapters where the characters uttered only short sentences like that, scattered among what seemed like a daily newspaper report, really makes one want to throw the book out the window.
Luckily I was reading an ebook that I got for free from a friend!

I considered abandoning the book, but the plot promised well and I hoped it would improve, so I forced myself to keep going on with the reading.
But as I said IT WAS SO BORING ! Eventually halfway through the book twists and turns began, some clues appeared and dialogues were finally more interesting (even if, unfortunately, never passionate and full of pathos as it should be in a compelling novel).
By now I had entered the story and so managed to get to the end to see the mystery solved, the villain punished and good people save.

The writing is very simple, indeed I never needed to consult the English-Italian vocabulary ( the book was not available in my native language... I know my English is not so good, then please, forgive any error you find in my review ).

This reading is recommended for 12 years old and up, but since it talks about pedophilia and it describes gruesome death sentences... I'd say it's better from 15 years old and up.

I don't understand why some readers expected something more in-depth about the composer Haydn: it's an adventure-mystery-fiction novel (and not a biography of a famous musician) with just a hint of romanticism (I wasn't looking for that, so it turned out fine, but if you want to read about love, then you have to read a different book ).

Summary : if the setting fascinates you and if you are patient enough to face a flat "newspaper" style reading (at least for half of the book), and you are not interested in love stories, THEN READ IT!

... otherwise forget it.

Join me on FB

Monday, May 29, 2023

Book review : The Story of the Trapp Family Singers by Maria Augusta von Trapp

The Story of the Trapp Family Singers
by Maria Augusta von Trapp

My rating: 5 of 5 stars

This is the book about Family Von Trapp's true story, the singing family story which inspired the 1965 well known musical film titled "THE SOUND OF MUSIC" directed by Robert Wise.
I loved this reading so much and actually the film is only about a very small part of everything the real Maria Von Trapp tells in her autobiographical book.

Maria tells us about 20 years of life and manages to do it in a simple, very smooth and often amusing way.

Her great faith in God (also witnessed in the film) gives a strong religious imprint to her family whole life and also to this book and this is something that probably not everyone might like or might be interested in, but I can assure you that you will not be bored on any page of this amazing memoir.

Everything we have seen in the film corresponds to the first pages of the book, then the story develops by telling events and anecdotes from the Von Trapp family's departure from Austria (to escape the Nazi regime they opposed to) up to the United States arrival, where they will face a thousand problems and experiences, performing as singers on tour from one state to another.

I started reading this book, because since my childhood my mom and I were (and still are) passionate about the musical film "The Sound of Music" and I was curious to know more about the history of this family.
The story reported in the book, after a brief introduction of how Maria arrives in the Von Trapp family (and we also saw it in the film), concerns the 10 years after the marriage, their travels in Austria and neighboring countries, the beautiful Austrian traditions and how the approach to music and singing occurred in a natural way. All of that was really fascinating!

Then the escape to the United States, their life in a new country, so different from their native country and from the European continent in so many aspects (material and emotional), but where they meet many new friends and who slowly manage to feel like their new and real forever home.

In this memoir Maria tells us, in a real witty way, all many adventures and problems they had to face even after their arrival in the United States.
It may seem absurd nowadays, where the western world is all uniformed to the same fashions and we all know the habits and customs of other countries and other continents, but 80 years ago Europe and the United States were two completely different worlds, in the city scenarios ... all 50,000 times bigger, modern and innovative, different in uses and customs and even in the way of speaking and I don't mean the differet language, but the difference in idioms, which still today makes it difficult to understand and express oneself in a foreign language.
It was really hard for them to get used to a completely different new world and start all over again, without money and without having been used to work (in Austria the commander Georg Von Trapp was a baron and he was rich).

The biggest obstacle was the war, which despite taking place in Europe, involving USA as well, also brought many serious practical difficulties in the United States.
The problems with the visa for the European fugitives (there was the risk that they were spies) and the consequent imprisonment, the ban on building and the use of materials except second-hand ones and therefore the difficulties in building a house, the rationing about food etc... being Italian I didn't know so much about American issues during the war years.

Very hard experiences at times, but which they, all together, have been able to change into something positive wich made their whole life truly extraordinary and so particular and different from the history of any other family.

I didn't expect to learn so much from this book : a history lesson about the 40s in USA and a lesson of resilience that left a big positive mark on my soul.

As I have already written, faith in God was a great and important component in their life journey, but the strength to react without ever giving up and the desire to improve and be self-sufficient in everything is a great merit of Mary and of all of them.

The book is written in a flowing and fun way to read, because Maria's character really was bizarre and likeable as everyone can see in the musical movie.
Maria made her gaffes and funny things came out of it, from all this emerges the portrait of a nice woman, but also a very strong and dominant person in everything, held in check (just a little) by her more calm husband Georg, who has made no small effort to get used to poverty and to the common society rules. Being an aristocrat, Georg Von Trapp considered shameful to work or even appear on stage, for the rest, however, he was a very good and man, very fond of his family and not so harsh as in the film).

While reading the book, I also looked for other articles on the web,to know more about the children in their adult life, the family house in Salzburg and the family houses built in America, Georg's death (described in every detail in the original English edition, but cut out in the Italian edition), the death of a daughter (the only one who died very young, while the others died between the ages of 80 and 97, while the youngest 2 children, born to Georg and Maria, are still alive ) and it was all so engaging!

After this first Maria's book I also read Von Trapp's daughter Agathe's memoirs, which can be considered a completion of this book.

You can read ONLINE FOR FREE the AGATHE'S MEMOIR HERE, just click Both books gave me so much serenity in reading them and the descriptions of a slice of life fascinated me from the first line to the last one!!

HIGHLY RECOMMENDED READING !!! ( my favorite in the last years ! ) :-)



--- LIBRO DISPONIBILE ANCHE IN ITALIANO - Recensione in italiano ---

Questo libro racconta la vera storia della famiglia Von Trapp, la storia familiare che ha ispirato il famoso film musicale del 1965 intitolato "THE SOUND OF MUSIC" diretto da Robert Wise.
Ho adorato questa lettura così tanto e in realtà il film rappresenta solo una piccolissima parte di tutto ciò che la vera Maria Von Trapp racconta nel suo libro autobiografico.

Maria ci racconta 20 anni di vita e riesce a farlo in modo semplice, molto scorrevole e spesso divertente.

La sua grande fede in Dio (testimoniata anche nel film) dà una forte impronta religiosa a tutta la sua vita familiare e di conseguenza anche a questo suo “memoir”, cosa che probabilmente non a tutti potrebbe piacere o interessare, ma posso assicurarvi che non vi annoierete in nessuna pagina di questo straordinario libro di memorie.

Tutto quello che abbiamo visto nel film corrisponde alle prime pagine del libro, poi la storia si sviluppa raccontando vicende e aneddoti dalla partenza della famiglia Von Trapp dall'Austria (per sfuggire al regime nazista a cui si opponevano) fino all'arrivo negli Stati Uniti, dove affronteranno mille problemi ed esperienze, esibendosi come cantanti in tournée da uno stato all'altro.

Ho iniziato a leggere questo libro, perché sin dalla mia infanzia mia madre ed io eravamo (e siamo tuttora) fans appassionate del musical "Tutti insieme appassionatamente" ed ero curiosa di saperne di più sulla storia reale ( e non romanzata )di questa famiglia.

La storia riportata nel libro, dopo una breve introduzione di come Maria comincia a far parte della famiglia Von Trapp (e l'abbiamo vista anche nel film), riguarda i 10 anni dopo il matrimonio, i loro viaggi in Austria e nei paesi limitrofi, le tradizioni austriache e come l'avvicinamento alla musica e al canto sia avvenuto in modo naturale. Tutto ciò è stato davvero affascinante!

Poi la fuga negli Stati Uniti, la loro vita in un paese nuovo, così diverso dal loro paese d'origine e dal continente europeo sotto tanti aspetti (materiali ed emotivi), ma dove incontreranno tanti nuovi amici e dove piano piano riusciranno a sentirsi “davvero a casa loro “, facendone la loro nuova patria per sempre.

In questo libro di memorie Maria ci racconta, in maniera davvero simpatica, tutte le tante avventure e le difficoltà che hanno dovuto affrontare anche dopo il loro arrivo negli Stati Uniti.
Può sembrare assurdo oggigiorno, ora che il mondo occidentale è tutto uniformato alle stesse mode e tutti conosciamo usi e costumi di altri paesi e di altri continenti, ma 80 anni fa Europa e Stati Uniti erano due mondi completamente diversi, negli scenari cittadini e naturali... tutto 50.000 volte più grande, tutto più moderno e innovativo rispetto alla vecchio continente, profonda diversità in usi e costumi, diversità nel modo di esprimersi e non intendo la diversa lingua, ma la differenza di modo di pensare e concepire la vita, la differenza di idiomi, che ancora oggi rende difficile la comprensione e l'esprimersi in una lingua straniera.
È stato davvero difficile per loro abituarsi a un nuovo mondo completamente diverso da quello in cui erano nati e cresciuti e ricominciare tutto da capo, senza soldi e senza essere stati abituati a lavorare (in Austria, infatti, il comandante Georg Von Trapp era un barone ed era molto ricco).

L'ostacolo maggiore fu dato dalle conseguenze della guerra, che pur svolgendosi in Europa, coinvolgendo anche gli Stati Uniti, portò anche nel nuovo mondo non poche e serie difficoltà pratiche.
I problemi con il visto per i fuggitivi europei (c'era il rischio che si trattasse di spie) e la conseguente carcerazione, il divieto di realizzare nuove costruzioni e di utilizzare materiali nuovi (potevano essere usati solo quelli di seconda mano ) e quindi l'impossibilità di potersi costruire una casa, il razionamento del cibo ecc... essendo italiana non conoscevo nei particolari la vita degli Americani durante gli anni della guerra.

La famiglia Von Trapp visse dunque esperienze spesso molto dure anche durante gli anni in cui erano ormai famosi.
Grazie al sentimento profondo che li univa, tutti insieme, seppero trasformare il negativo in qualcosa di positivo e ciò rese tutta la loro vita davvero straordinaria e così particolare e diversa dalla storia di qualsiasi altra famiglia.

Ciò che non mi aspettavo da questo libro era di imparare una lezione di storia sugli anni '40 negli Stati Uniti e soprattutto una lezione di resilienza e tenacia, che ha lasciato un grande segno positivo nella mia anima.

Come ho già scritto, la fede in Dio è stata una grande e importante componente nel loro cammino di vita, ma la forza di reagire senza mai arrendersi e la voglia di migliorarsi ed essere autosufficienti in tutto è un grande merito di Maria e di tutta la Famiglia Von Trapp.

Il libro è scritto in modo scorrevole e divertente da leggere, perché Maria era fu realmente una persona bizzarra e simpatica così come rappresentata nel film musicale e la sua spontaneità fu proprio uno dei suoi punti di forza.
Maria ha fatto le sue gaffe e ne sono venute fuori cose buffe, emerge il ritratto di una donna simpatica, ma anche forte e dall'energia dominante su tutti, tenuta a freno (poco) dal più pacato marito Georg, che fece non pochi sforzi per abituarsi alla povertà e alle comuni regole della società. Essendo un aristocratico, Georg Von Trapp considerava vergognoso lavorare o anche solo apparire sul palco, per il resto, invece, era un uomo molto buono, molto affezionato alla sua famiglia e non così severo come rappresentato nel film.

Durante la lettura del libro ho cercato anche altri articoli sul web, per saperne di più sui bambini Von Trapp nella loro vita adulta ( dopo i 20 descritti nel libro ), la residenza di famiglia a Salisburgo e la fattoria costruita in America, la morte di Georg (descritta in ogni dettaglio nell'originale inglese edizione, ma tagliata nell'edizione italiana), la morte di una figlia (l'unica morta giovanissima, mentre gli altre sono morti tra gli 80 e i 97 anni, e due di loro sono ancora vivi) ed è stato tutto così coinvolgente!

CONSIGLIO A TUTTI VIVAMENTE DI LEGGERLO ! E se non lo trovate in negozio o negli shoipping online, potrete sicuramente trovare copie usate sul web :-)

Join me on FB Tizi Cozy Corner page to be always updated on new posts

Book review : Whisper of Jasmine by Deanna Raybourn

Whisper of Jasmine City of Jasmine book #0.5 by Deanna Raybourn A Sweet and Intriguing Prelude GENRE : #historic...